Will There Ever Be Peace Between Israel and the Palestinians?

If you really want to be depressed, contemplate the chance of success for peace between Israel and the Palestinians. The issues between them seem insurmountable.

As long as Israel holds the West Bank it is ruling a recalcitrant population. But if it withdraws to the 1967 borders, which are in reality the 1949 armistice lines, the narrow middle of the country could be cut in half by an Arab/Palestinian attack.

Israel is composed of leftists and secularists who are willing to withdraw
from some or all of the West Bank. It is also composed of the right and the ultra-religious, some of whom are willing to live in peace in the West Bank with the Palestinians, whether the area is called Judaea and Samaria or Palestine.

The Palestinians seem to want the West Bank Judenrein, something it was not before the Jordanians invaded in 1948. Given the current realities, it is not possible to get 500,000 religious and nationalistic Jews to withdraw without an Israeli civil war.

Based on history, if Israel does withdraw, the future of peace is less than assured.
When Israel withdrew from Lebanon, it got Hezbollah; when it withdrew from Gaza,
it got Hamas. If it withdraws from the West Bank, it could get a militarized Palestine
importing arms and rockets from Syria, Lebanon and Gaza. If Jordan falls to the
majority Palestinian inhabitants, the future is bleak for Israel.

When the Palestinians speak in English, they proclaim that Israel must withdraw
to the 1967 borders. When they speak in Arabic, they frequently say that the Jewish state of Israel must be destroyed and that not one inch of the area can ever be in Jewish hands.

The western press and many of their reporters who lean to the left always seem to favor the underdog. Israel is far stronger than the Palestinians, so there is little doubt of their allegiance. The UN, with a core of Arab and other third-world countries, is understandably anti-Israel, sometimes even shading into anti-Jewish. With more than twenty wars going on between Islamic extremists and what they consider to be infidels, it is surprising that the UN mostly criticizes Israel. Or maybe not.

With Israel’s hundreds of nuclear and other sophisticated weapons, you would have
to be insane to try to destroy it. The Arab terrorist groups must know what the
endgame would be. The question is: Are they fanatical enough to try it anyway?

Hezbollah Goading Israel Into Overreacting

Hassan Nasrallah, the Secretary-General of Hezbollah, said today that Hezbollah was responsible for the drone that entered Israeli airspace last week. The drone was designed by Iran, assembled by Hezbollah in Lebanon, and then launched by Hezbollah.

It’s not the first time (that a drone was sent) and it will not be the last. We can reach all the zones” of Israel, said Nasrallah, referring back to a 2006 incident in which a Hezbollah drone badly damaged an Israeli warship.

The drone “overflew sensitive and important installations for dozens of kilometers until the enemy spotted it near (the nuclear site) Dimona”, said Nasrallah.

Nasrallah “wants to provoke Israel and play on Arab feelings that he is still holding the flag of the Arab resistance against Israel” said Sami Nader, professor of international relations at St. Joseph University in Beirut.

As a militant group, Hezbollah is most powerful and receives most of its support during wartime. In sending the drone into Israeli airspace, Hezbollah hopes to goad Israel into overreacting, thus justifying its own presence in Lebanon as well as garnering local support.

The drone incident also helps Hezbollah distract attention from the uprising in Syria against its ally Bashar al-Assad. Nasrallah said, “The regime in Syria doesn’t need us or anyone else to fight alongside it“, however opposition groups have claimed that Hezbollah members are fighting alongside Assad’s army.

Launching the drone into Israeli airspace was also a move by Hezbollah on behalf of Iran. Hezbollah receives financial and political assistance, as well as weapons and training from Iran. Part of the drone’s job may have been to gain intel on Israel’s military and nuclear sites to share with Iran.

Both Iran and Israel have been engaged in a cold war that is threatening to turn hot. Iran has fought Israel by proxy using Hezbollah, and any antagonizing that Hezbollah does to Israel will distact Israel from its bigger threat, Iran.

If Hezbollah successfully goads Israel into retaliating, the left would see it as an example of how violent and reckless Israel is, and as evidence for Iran being the non-belligerent one. If Israel strikes Hezbollah in Lebanon, it may also give Lebanon and their allies an excuse to join the fight against Israel.

The best move Israel can make at this point regarding the drone incident is to not react to Hezbollah’s provocations. The world opinion will not be with Israel if any retaliation is made.